SeedsNow Review 2025: Best Heirloom Seeds for Serious Gardeners?

After years of ordering heirloom seeds, vegetable seeds, and flower seeds from countless online seed companies, I've learned the hard way that not all seed suppliers are created equal. Nothing's more frustrating than dealing with poor germination rates, overpriced seed packets, or seeds that don't grow true to their variety descriptions.

That's why when fellow organic gardeners kept raving about SeedsNow's heirloom vegetable seeds and rare flower varieties, I had to put them through my own testing process. I've now placed multiple orders, grown out their heritage seeds across several growing seasons, and can give you the real scoop on whether this seed company delivers quality seeds worth your gardening budget.

Spoiler alert: SeedsNow has seriously impressed me and become one of my top recommendations for quality heirloom seeds, but there's definitely some important stuff you need to know before ordering.

What Makes SeedsNow Stand Out in the Crowded Seed Market

The seed industry is packed with companies selling everything from hybrid seeds to GMO varieties, but SeedsNow has carved out a solid niche focusing on heirloom seeds, non-GMO varieties, and hard-to-find cultivars that you definitely won't see at your local garden center or big box store.

They're not trying to compete on price with mass-market seed companies. Instead, they're going after quality-conscious gardeners who want access to heritage varieties, organic seeds, and specialty cultivars that have real stories behind them.

What really caught my attention was their incredible selection of unusual heirloom varieties. While most online seed companies stick to standard tomato varieties and basic lettuce seeds, SeedsNow carries amazing stuff like purple heritage carrots, glass gem corn seeds, and rare bean varieties that have been passed down through generations of seed savers.

Their website makes it clear that all their seeds are non-GMO, and many carry organic certification - which matters a lot to home gardeners who want to know exactly what they're growing in their vegetable gardens. Plus, they provide detailed growing guides for each heirloom variety, including specific information about days to maturity, plant spacing, and region-specific growing tips.

The company's been operating since 2009, so they're definitely not some fly-by-night seed operation. They're Connecticut-based and seem to really understand what serious gardeners are looking for in terms of both common varieties and rare seeds that you can't find anywhere else.

Seed Quality Testing: Do These Seeds Actually Grow?

Here's what every gardener really wants to know - do SeedsNow's seeds actually germinate and produce healthy plants? I've been testing their vegetable seeds, flower seeds, and herb varieties across multiple growing seasons, and honestly, their seed germination rates have been consistently excellent.

Their heirloom tomato seeds have been absolute standouts. I've grown their Cherokee Purple heirloom tomatoes, Brandywine varieties, and several cherry tomato cultivars with germination rates consistently above 80-85%. The plants grew exactly true to type and produced the exact tomato varieties described on the seed packets.

The herb seed varieties have been equally reliable for my herb garden. Their basil seed collection - including unique varieties like African Blue basil and Cardinal basil - germinated quickly and produced robust herb plants. The oregano seeds and thyme varieties grew into flavorful plants that perfectly matched their variety descriptions.

But here's where I've been really blown away: their flower seed selection. Too many seed companies treat flower varieties as afterthoughts, but SeedsNow's cosmos seeds, zinnia varieties, and sunflower seeds have produced absolutely stunning results in my test gardens. Their cut flower seed mixes have been particularly successful for creating gorgeous cutting gardens.

The seed packaging is professional with clear planting instructions and realistic expiration dates. Seeds arrive in well-sealed packets with detailed growing information that goes way beyond the basic stuff you get from most seed suppliers.

Heirloom Variety Selection: Unique Seeds You Can't Find Everywhere

This is honestly where SeedsNow absolutely shines compared to other online seed companies. While you can find standard vegetable varieties cheaper elsewhere, their selection of rare heirloom varieties and unique cultivars is genuinely impressive for serious gardeners.

Their heirloom tomato collection goes way beyond typical garden center offerings. They carry incredible varieties like Black Krim tomatoes, Green Zebra heirlooms, and Paul Robeson tomatoes that you'll rarely find at other seed suppliers. These aren't just novelty varieties either - they're productive, incredibly flavorful heritage tomatoes with fascinating histories.

The bean seed collection is particularly strong for anyone interested in heritage varieties. They offer everything from classic Cherokee Trail of Tears beans to unusual climbing bean varieties that double as beautiful ornamental plants. I've had amazing success with their yard-long Asian beans and their colorful dry bean heirlooms.

Their flower seed selection includes both popular garden favorites and unusual heirloom varieties that add real visual interest to flower gardens. The four o'clock seed collection and morning glory varieties have been absolute showstoppers in my test plots, attracting tons of compliments from other gardeners.

What I really appreciate is that they provide detailed background information about many of their heritage varieties, including the history behind heirloom seeds and tips for saving seeds from your harvest.

Ready to explore SeedsNow's incredible selection of heirloom and specialty seeds? We've partnered with SeedsNow to give you access to their complete catalog of rare varieties, heritage vegetables, and unique flower seeds. Whether you're searching for unusual tomato heirlooms, heritage bean varieties, or unique flower cultivars, their quality seed selection can seriously upgrade your garden game. Browse their full collection and start planning your most interesting garden yet.

Seed Pricing: Great Value for Quality Heirloom Varieties

Let's talk real numbers about SeedsNow's pricing, because value matters when you're planning your garden budget. Their seed packets typically run $2-5 for vegetable varieties and $2-3 for flower seeds, which is totally reasonable when you consider the quality heirloom varieties and consistent germination rates you're getting.

Here's the thing about seed costs that every gardener should understand: when you break down pricing per plant, even quality seeds are incredibly economical compared to buying seedlings at nurseries. A $3 heirloom tomato seed packet might contain 25+ seeds, making each tomato plant cost about 12 cents - way cheaper than buying a single organic tomato seedling at the garden center.

The value gets even better when you consider what you're actually getting. These are carefully maintained heirloom varieties with excellent germination rates, not mass-produced hybrid seeds that have been sitting in warehouses for years. Many of their heritage varieties are small-batch seed productions that you simply can't find at local garden stores.

For unique heirloom varieties and reliable seed quality, SeedsNow's pricing is actually quite competitive within the specialty seed market. You're paying for access to rare varieties that would be impossible to find locally, plus the confidence that comes with consistent seed performance.

Customer Service and Seed Shipping Experience

I've placed multiple seed orders with SeedsNow over the years for my vegetable garden and flower beds, and their customer service has been consistently reliable. Seed orders typically ship within 2-3 business days, and their packaging protects seeds well during transit.

They offer reasonable shipping rates and frequently run free shipping promotions during peak seed ordering season in late winter and early spring. International shipping is available for overseas gardeners, though I can't personally speak to that experience.

The one time I had issues with a batch of flower seeds that didn't germinate well, their customer service team was responsive and offered to replace the seeds without any hassle. That kind of guarantee behind their seed products gives me real confidence in recommending them to other gardeners.

Growing Instructions and Gardening Support

This is honestly an area where SeedsNow really excels compared to many other seed companies. Each heirloom variety comes with detailed growing information that goes way beyond the basic planting depth and spacing you'll find on most seed packets.

They provide specific information about soil preferences, optimal planting times for different growing zones, spacing recommendations for maximum yields, and detailed harvesting tips. For unusual heritage varieties, this detailed growing information can make the difference between gardening success and complete failure.

Their website also includes comprehensive growing guides and cultivation tips for many of their specialty varieties. If you're trying something new like ground cherries or glass gem corn, having access to expert growing advice is invaluable for first-time growers.

Who Should Choose SeedsNow for Their Garden Seeds

SeedsNow makes perfect sense for gardeners who want access to unique heirloom varieties and value reliable seed quality. If you're interested in heritage vegetables, rare flower varieties, or cultivars with interesting historical backgrounds, they offer excellent value for serious gardeners.

They're also ideal for organic gardeners who want confidence in their seed sources and appreciate detailed growing information. The combination of unusual varieties and reliable seed performance makes them a smart choice for experienced gardeners and ambitious beginners alike.

Whether you're just starting your first vegetable garden or you're an experienced grower looking for new varieties to try, SeedsNow's reasonable pricing and quality seed selection make them accessible to most gardening budgets.

Comparing SeedsNow to Other Seed Companies

When compared to major seed suppliers like Burpee or Ferry-Morse, SeedsNow offers way more unique heirloom varieties with competitive pricing for specialty seeds. Their seed quality consistently matches or exceeds the big-name companies, making them excellent value for quality-conscious gardeners.

Compared to other heirloom specialists like Baker Creek Seeds or Seed Savers Exchange, SeedsNow holds its own in terms of variety selection and seed quality, with very reasonable pricing for the specialty seed market.

Their customer service and shipping reliability puts them ahead of many smaller specialty seed suppliers who might have great heritage varieties but inconsistent order fulfillment.

Final Verdict: Should You Order Seeds from SeedsNow?

After multiple growing seasons testing SeedsNow's vegetable seeds, flower varieties, and herb seeds, I can confidently recommend them for gardeners who value variety, quality, and reliability at fair prices.

Their seed germination rates are consistently excellent, their unusual heirloom varieties perform exactly as promised, and their customer service stands behind their seed products. The detailed growing information helps ensure success, especially when you're trying unfamiliar heritage varieties.

The pricing is fair and reasonable for the quality heirloom seeds and unique varieties you're getting. While you might save a few cents on basic varieties elsewhere, for specialty seeds and guaranteed seed performance, SeedsNow offers excellent value.

They've definitely earned a permanent spot in my annual seed ordering routine, particularly when I want to try new heirloom varieties and need confidence that my seeds will perform as expected. For gardeners who appreciate seed quality and variety at reasonable prices, SeedsNow is absolutely worth trying for your next garden season.

Join Our Growing Urban Plant Community

🌿 Grow Your Green Space—One Tip at a Time

Subscribe to the Balcony Bloomers newsletter and get:

🌱 Weekly balcony gardening tips for small spaces 🪴 Exclusive guides to growing herbs, veggies & flowers 🧪 Product reviews on planters, tools & eco-friendly gear 🎁 Free downloads, seasonal planting checklists & more

👉 Join 5,000+ city gardeners transforming their balconies into lush retreats. It’s FREE—and your plants will thank you.